Looking at this Tshuveh (Siman 'ט) with an iota of objectivity you might say that he was using RAYH"K to make his point, and not so much because he held of him as a m'kor. Sort of like what the Satmarers do when they wanna make a point regarding their favorite subject, Zionism. They'll bring Belzer letters and show it to a Belzer, and then they'll show letters from the Rebbe Rashab to a Lubavitcher, and so on. But then again, we all know that when asked why he's taking Rav Weisz as dayan in the Edah when he's not a kano'i, the Satmar Rov said that a Talmid Chochom can become a kano'i, a kano'i won't become a talmid chochom so quickly... Which is what happened; Rav Weisz fell in line with the Edah theology very nicely, just like the SR foretold. We bring you the Tshuveh in Minchas Yitzchok, and then the Tshuveh in Kol Yisroel from Rav Kook in 1933.
קול ישראל courtesy of תוך כדי דיבור on Otzar haChochmah. Minchas Yitzchok courtesy of HebrewBooks.
Hirshel
ReplyDeleteFYI
2 icons in the willi crowd stem from Rav Weber (Shezuri)the person to whom the responsa of Rav Kook, is intended.
Rav Gelbman the offical(by the Zali group) baker of the 55 volumes Moshian Shel Yisroel.
Rav Pinki Weber(Shezuri) the talented Badchan, who lately printed a nice sefer al hatorah,
I had no idea! who was the 1st one in America? And I thought that Shezuri was a Lelover Chossid?
ReplyDeleteWasn't r'moshe veyber from yerushalayim, a chbdsker, who had some shayches with rav kook?
ReplyDeleteIdo erlich,(father of mishpachas aryeh ehrlich) who became a lubab, and adopted r'moshe(or was it the other way around...)
r'moshe was a tsadik that even non lubob held of
Weber was a lelover still from rdtz''sh z''l.
Deletebut apparently that was in the Holy Land only. They were Sanzer Chassidim
ReplyDeleteHirshel
ReplyDelete"I had no idea! who was the 1st one in America?"
what dont you know? I wrote that Gelbman is a einikel from Rav Kooks Mazkir Shezuri..
I think that he is a einikel from the famous or infamous Rav of Ada
who was the first Weber in America is what I wanna know?
ReplyDeleteThe "Rav Ada Bar Ahva" was Shezuri's father, no?
Yes
DeleteHirshel
ReplyDelete"The "Rav Ada Bar Ahva" was Shezuri's father, no?
I dont know if a einikel or a son?
Shezuri should of been a bobover chosid, The first Reb Shlomele of bobov was on his side, by the parsha
Wich parsha?
Deleteר' שמואל אהרן וועבר-שזורי היה בנו של ר' בן-ציון וועבער
ReplyDeleteערכו באינצ. תדהר:
http://www.tidhar.tourolib.org/tidhar/view/3/1224
ר' בן-ציון היה בנן של הרב מאדא, ר' מרדכי אליעזר וועבער ז"ל שעלה לאר"י
הנה מאמר בהמבשר מדור 'למשפחתום' למשפחת וובר:
http://www.shturem.net/index.php?section=news&id=38131
תודה לך, ר' ארץ ישראל
ReplyDelete