@chortkover fraud עירין קדישין is spelled and pronounced Irin not Urin. Secondly I have the new edition of the sefer. After perusing the indexes for all references to שער, זקן ודעת. I came up empty. אדרבה if you have a מראה מקום I'd love to see it. I've gone through very significant amount of the seforim.
Not a harry If you did not see it there, then I have to recheck the source. I definitely saw it and I checked my brain with a friend that has vast knowledge in Chasidic Seforim and Chasidic Sipurim, he verified it too. I will check it in a day or 2 in Oirois Yisroel of Mosad Harim Levin, which has no index...and other places
.jpg)
david assaf's book says R Israel didnt have a beard.
ReplyDeletenot that we need Assaf for that... Maybe it's poetic license
ReplyDeleteCompare the צורה to his direct descendants...
ReplyDeletepainting a beard on a clean shaven man is more than a poetic license, no? its a false representation.
ReplyDeleteWhat is assaf's claim based on? He wasn't clean shaven, that's a certainty.
ReplyDeletebased on several contemporary sources, diaries, etc..
ReplyDeleteNot a Harry
ReplyDeletethere are some ideas about short beards in the sefer Urin Kadoishin, that long hair resembles less daas...
saw it long ago...
please explain that short beard short on daas source
ReplyDeletewhat is the source of this, was i discovered etc?
ReplyDeletei found it in an auction book from 2013
ReplyDeleteits in Urin Kadishin
ReplyDeletelook it up for yourself and explain it to me
come on!
ReplyDeletedon't be so naive. it could be a third generation einekel
Irin kadishin only mentions not having a chup. Nothing else about hair/beard.
ReplyDeletenot a harry
ReplyDeleteI think you are mistaking,
its not in Hebrewbooks so I can not proof it for sure
I think the Kedusaht Levie talks about a bloiris
@chortkover fraud
ReplyDeleteעירין קדישין is spelled and pronounced Irin not Urin. Secondly I have the new edition of the sefer. After perusing the indexes for all references to שער, זקן ודעת. I came up empty. אדרבה if you have a מראה מקום I'd love to see it. I've gone through very significant amount of the seforim.
NAH
ReplyDeletelook in שארית ישראל page 147 ותמצא נחת
אינו תחת ידי כעת
ReplyDeletePlease post..
Not a harry
ReplyDeleteIf you did not see it there, then I have to recheck the source.
I definitely saw it and I checked my brain with a friend that has vast knowledge in Chasidic Seforim and Chasidic Sipurim, he verified it too.
I will check it in a day or 2 in Oirois Yisroel of Mosad Harim Levin, which has no index...and other places
It's as reliable as the picture of the alter rebbe (r. Shmarya schn. must have been an impressive looking fellows).
ReplyDeleteder heiliger Rizhiner did not have a beard but only 26 hairs.
ReplyDeleteBroght down in a lot of maise sforim and it is mekibel by all his einiklech.
That's true. And I heard that the Boyan rabbe and other einiklach wore not me label the pic
Delete