Wednesday, May 27, 2015

Munkacs profiles אד"ל

See pages 8-11. It looks like they bought into it, hook, line and sinker. All it takes is buying the Satmar Newspapers over the years and you're sold on what they sell you. I would expect the publishers of this journal to know better. But I guess since Minchas Elozor writes a nice letter to him... and since he was a zealot like the ME, it's all good. Whatever.

39 comments:

Superintendant Chalmers said...

Is it really so hurtful to you that they have a write-up on the Malach? No offense but grow up.

vats the matter said...

so they wrote about someone u don't like ......
common grow up

Hirshel Tzig - הירשל ציג said...

ok, I"ll forget about it

Superintendant Chalmers said...

I thoroughly enjoyed the read though, thanks for posting it.

(See, even if we have different opinions, we can still be cordial. Just like Munkatch and Belz and Lubavitch and Sat...oh wait...)

ספינקער שגץ said...

עבר ושנה נעשה לו כהיתר, אתה כתבת פאשקוויל בנוסח רשת על הרב בדומה למלאך ד"צ פעמיים ושלוש וגם על התלמידים החשובים שלו, הלא דבר הוא! ומה פשעו כי דלגת אחריו, אני חושב שצריכים לעשות מחאה גדולה בעשי"ת הבאים עלנו נגד המשרדים שלך בעיר רבתי בגויים, ואף רעזעלוציע איך לטפל עם הפראמינאנטע שמות שמופיע כאן, אולי ישובו מדרכך וחי

קאפוסטער said...

המלאך הגואל אותנו מכל רע יברך את הנער הירשעלע שישובו מדרכיו שהוא לכאורה נגד שיטת הממ"ש לקרב הרחוקים ובל ידח ממנו נדח, אף המלאכים בכלל היתה

brooklyn demo club said...

we will wait, but how long is this "...." please send your privy info here ASAP

brooklyn demo club said...

So hirshel you're looking for friends with benefits, mazel u'brucu.

Angel of Hewes street said...

Kapuster
Mitzvas Ahacas yisroel is only for human beings, not for angels

Chaim Mendel said...

there is a long essay style foreword, to the pamphlet with a nice idea on Mazel, based on words of Munkacher Ruv ZYA that his advice that worked for people came from his mazel, very well done. But I think they are blowing out of proportion the number of chasidim that he had.
Munkach did not have tens of thousands of chasidim before the histalkus.
why kill a good article with nonsense.

Family biased said...

Its ironic that Malochim as the writer Rapaport (a nice malochim family) quote the son of the Malach, was he holier then Reb Shraga Fievel?
he is being quoted as torah min hashomaim, in their universe you dont befriend guys like him,....

קאפוסטער said...

א"ר יוחנן מאי דכתיב (מלאכי ב) כי שפתי כהן ישמרו דעת ותורה יבקשו מפיהו כי מלאך ה' צבאות הוא אם דומה הרב למלאך ה' יבקשו תורה מפיו ואם לאו אל יבקשו תורה מפיו

Angel of Hewes street said...

Kapuster
the talmud chuchem is Doimeh to a a angel
but the Hewes street people are the ZACH alien

Superintendant Chalmers said...

I know it's been said that the Malach was a talmid of R Chaim Brisker - anyone know where/when/how long/what the context of this relationship was?

חיים בער said...

I wouldn't diminish a bit of his great influence in that hemisphere, in his later days he didn't feel well, צרת בעלז, צרת הבת, ונגע הציונת קצרו רוחו הגדול ויקיום בו הוזרח השמש-ובא השמש שמש של סאטמאר, שבאמת הוא ז"ל אהב אותו מכל! וגם שלח אנשים ליועץ בו, וגם כתב מכתב שהוא ז"ל יכול לטהר את כל א"י מדן עד באר שבע, אולם ויקנאו "בו" אחיו. . ואכמ"ל בזה

yankel said...

Wow! This fellow really occupies your nightmares. What did he really do to chabad that they still quote him, deal with him, curse him etc.? Where does all this hate come from?
I guess I cannot relate to the idea of people taking these things seriously. I mean, I get the idea, maybe, of a person holding a grudge. If you mess something up for someone, I could understand his holding a grudge for years. But this fellow, at worst, did something against chabad. So everyone who believes in chabad takes this personally?! Does the whole humanity get swallowed up by the party to which you belong? This is true about many parties and clubs that claim to be chassidus so they can somehow blame the baal shem tov for their business interests. But chabad has to be one of the worst in this.
Get a life! literally. You are a carbon based life form, a children of parents, a parent of children. Chabad is only incidental to your existence.

Superintendant Chalmers said...

One other question which I find puzzling - how is it possible for someone to be both a lawyer, and at the same time a kanai against secular education?

satmar butcher shop said...

tzig "Minchas Elozor writes a nice letter to him... "

he is looking for jacobs latter to get a malach!
goat head will meet rosh hashanah .

והוא באחד ומי ישובנו

ר"ת said...

אלא מאי? עשה תשובה ובלי המצוה טאנקן, וזה א"א! א"כ הדרי קושיא לדוכתי

Hartz shmartz said...

yankel your comment is already longer than hirshel's.

wachtfogel said...

the jewish world use to be divided between chasidus and hisnagdus, now it's in essence divided between satmar & affiliates ( inc. all kind of chssidus and musnagdus) vs. the rest .

yeshivaman said...

He wasn't a talmid of r' Chaim but of another litvishe gaon (I forgot the name that was a talmid or תלמיד תלמידו of r' Menashe iliar) but he used to talk in learning and sefer hamoireh with R' chaim. In
מגד גבעות עולם he discusses him. This is all despite his negative opinion of misnagdim. It's just funny.because he was one of the chashuve chabad chassidim that his aveira was that he had his own opinion and he didn't buy in to everything hook line and sinker. http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=15688&st=&pgnum=18&hilite= אד"ל ר"ת ר' אברהם דוב לוין זי"ע.

yeshivaman said...

there's also a lot about the malach in chabad portraits by rabbi Chaim Dalfin

simple simon said...

yankel:Get a life! literally

hirshe, l yankel said do as i say, not as i do, familiar ?

kollel dweller said...

thanks for sharing.

rabba mindel said...

הירשל, אל ירך לבך בתתן לך as they say you can't attack the message, attack the messenger! old dog new tricks.

munkatcher and proud said...

munkatch uber allas!

Urshever Dayan said...

ר"ת said...
אלא מאי? עשה תשובה ובלי המצוה טאנקן, וזה א"א! א"כ הדרי קושיא לדוכתי

When did the holy Minchas Eluzer and his talmid the holy Shoproner repent for studying secular studies????
did u ever hear the saying
Kol Boehho Loi Yeshivim acronym for Bichel?
Klotz Kasha!!!!!

Jack Lew. subscriber said...

tzig: All it takes is buying the Satmar Newspapers over the years and you're sold on what they sell you.

thanks for promoting us to your many shades of readers letting them know where to place their ad's .

sincerely,
der yid
der blatt
the zeitung

JJJ said...

when did Minchos Elozor study secular?

Shoprner was allowed to as he was a Hirschian, anyways he repented by becoming Satmar

Urshever Dayan said...

ישיבה של מעלה said...
דער תירוץ איז זה עשה תשובה וזו לא
who did teshuva?

abc said...

not the one who never acknowledged sinning.

abc said...

drink your milk sweet dreams

Superintendant Chalmers said...

I think that was an answer to my question of how BZ Weberman was a lawyer, and also a kanai against secular studies.

shraga favel II said...

not so sup, he did not send his kids to college that proofs he did repent, and as תשובת המשקל he send them to study מפי מלאך בעצם

לאפן טאטר said...


עובדא ידענא ששמעתי מפי הבעל המעשה נ"י . כשהרב"י מסאטמאר ז"ל בא לכאן ערך שלחנו הטהור חוהמ"ס בביהמ"ד דחסידי סטאלין הוא ואחיו שהי' מתלמידי המלאך ז"ל והי' מלובשים בבגדי חסידות ובקצותיו תלתלים אורך אמה אחד, ומהבאים לשלחנו! ורביז"ל שאל עליהם מי הם? ויען האם זה מלאכים דפה, כלומר אמעריקאנער מלאכים ורבינו נהנה מזה כי הכרת פניהם ענתה עליהם שהם זרע ברך ד' ואמר: ואמר די וועלט פרעגט פארוואס האט מען גיגעבן די תורה אין א מדבר אין נישט ערגעצווי אין א מדינה, נאר וואזשע דען ווען מ'גיט איהר אין א מדינה וואלט מען גיזאגט דאס באלאנגט נאר צי די מדינה, אבער מ'האט עס גיגעבטן און מדבר ס'באלאנגט צי יעדן. והראה עליהם (מעשה ידי מלאך) ואמר כנראה ס'באלאנגט אין אמעריקא אויך. ע"כ

Anonymous said...

why does this malach disturb people
today the only one who remembers him is Rav Webberman who became a lubavitch chosid please can some answer me where I live in Europe the malachoim are the extreme of the extreme they will print and distribute pamphlets against everything they see as a heresy to yiddiskeit but to do a favour for a fellow jew they will go over the top to do it interesting people

אבא מלאך free boiler service said...

don't aggravate yourself stay away let them live in peace .

m. buber from boyborik said...

there is alot of malochem all over, some of them after they do their duty (shslicus) they stay on the ground and become like penguins, with great effort they still can fly.