Wednesday, January 11, 2006

On Accents



(Nitra Yeshiva Students during WWII)

In a setting today where most of the interacting between kids is done in English, the consequences are many, what I'll speak about is what happens next, and what's most disheartening to me. Maybe it's from watching and listening to too much Uncle Moishy, and maybe it's natural for English-speaking kids these days, but it's too much to handle. I'm speaking of a total "Anglicization" of everything and anything Hebrew. The Tzeyrey has become a Segol, the Cholom a Kometz, and let's not talk about the Reish and what that sounds like now. Let me give "ah ferinstance".

In Bentchen:
1) U'vtuvoy Hagodul, instead of Godoyl. (or HaGodeyl) :)
2) Baavur Shmoy Hagodul, instead of HaGodoyl. (or HaGodeyl) :)
3) Umeitiv Lakul, instead of Lakoyl. (or LaKeyl) :)
4) HaZon es Hakul, instead of Hakoyl. (or HaKeyl) :)

In Krias Shma:
1) Shma Yisroel, instead of Yisroeyl.
2) Beyodcho.... Hashem Kel Emes, instead of Keyl.

The list goes on, and it drives me crazy! Why must Chasidishe boys sound like Bais Yaakov girls?!

I don't want to pressure kids to sound and speak a certain way because I'm afraid they'll grow to up resent the Yiddish language, and everything it stands for. So my question is as follows; How do we go about rectifying the situation without the afore-mentioned problems arising?

Any intelligent input would be appreciated.


(Photo by Roman Vishniac)

Sunday, January 8, 2006

Dr. Twerski, Only Whistleblowing?



This is not meant to "knock" the illustrious Twerski family of Milwaukeee. They have accomplished much for Yiddishkeit, including a fine community in Milwaukee, much fine Jewish literature, and have been a light unto the nations. There's also the lineage that can be traced to the Alter and Mitteler Rebbes, something close to my heart. Rather, it's an observation I've made regarding the good Rabbi Dr. Abraham Twerski of Pittsburgh, Pa. He seems to be intent on calling out and publicizing the ineffecacies and shortcomings of Jews, especially Religious and "Charedim". Whether it be Alcoholoism, Drugs, Domestic Abuse, and Compulsive Gambling, he's there to say "us too", and we're no better than some other groups.

Here's Exhibit A, a Speech on "The truth about Gambling in the Jewish Community", held at a Shul in New Jersey. Listen if you have the time, and tell me if you don't think he's exxagerating the problem. That's not to say that the problems don't exist and that they don't need to be dealt with, but does the alarm need to be sounded like he does?

I have a sneaking suspicion that it's got something to do with him feeling somewhat out of the mainstream, with his family growing up in America and the subsequent college education of all of father's children, something unheard of even amongst the college-educated Chassidim themselves. I may, however, be totally wrong. His brother Aron Twerski, although he's risen to beome the dean of Hofstra Law School, maybe by living in Boro Park, has become SO mainstream that he's a lecturer at Agudah conventions, and it don't get more "Mainstream" than that.

(EDITED ON 1/13/05)

Friday, January 6, 2006

The Algemeiner - at a crossroads



I never really was a fan of the Algemeiner Journal growing up. I thought that as part of my "responsibility" to Lubavitch I had to buy the paper, just like the Kfar Chabad. What I never did understand was why it was so important to have pictures of heavily-bejeweled overaged women sipping champagne with Rabbi Arthur Schneier at a dinner for "Ketzelle" and Yeshivat Beit E-l, or why it was so important to have Sam Domb mentioned there every single week. I believe others had the same questions, and it showed in the ever-decreasing number of subscribers. Gershon Jacobson himself, for some reason, didn't notice that fact, he would say "אין מעקסיקע אליין האב איך צען טויזנט שובשקרייבערס" . Anyway, times have changed since then, and never more so since the passing of its beloved "REDAKTER" and founder Reb Gershon Ber.

New blood has taken over the reins, and with that comes new ideas. There now is much to read, and not just the same old news that we read elsewhere translated to Yiddish. On the advice of our commentor "C" I have taken a new interest in the paper and in the online edition, and boy, was I surprised. Now chock full of sheine vertelach, Zichraynes, opinions, as well as news, the paper can now keep you occupied for the full 45 minute train ride home!

In today's day and age of "שיינע שידוך געשלאסען בבית קאסאן-טאהש" and other Yiddish "stories" of non-interest that the other Yiddish papers provide, the market of un-Satmar affiliated Yiddish readers is ripe for the taking. If they'd like they can really jump start this baby and have a 30-year head start to boot. I don't know if that's what the Jacobsons have in mind but they seem to be headed in the right direction.

Let's hope they don't blow this chance.

?דו הערסט מיר יוס'ל

זכרון להולכים


Reb Berish Mandelbaum of YU


Reb Levi Itche Shapiro of Crown Heights
r-l front row: Nochum Shapiro, Sydney; HaRav AY Schwei; Nachman Shapiro of CH;RLYS.
r-l back row: Itche Mishulovin, son-in-law; 2 of Levi Itche's grandsons.

Thursday, January 5, 2006

Who's the photographer here?




That's right, !אויך אן אונזערער

Samary Gurary

Crimea, Yalta.
The meeting of the heads of the three allied countries – Roosevelt, Stalin and Churchill
February , 1945
Collection of Moscow House of Photography


א פרייליכען ה' טבת אלעמען

Wednesday, January 4, 2006

Book Review



Rabbi Ephraim Oshry conducts a memorial service

“The Annihilation of Lithuanian Jewry”
By HaRav Efrayim Oshri z”l
Translated by Yehoshua Lehman
Judaica Press, 1995


I have yet to read all of the book, but what I have read is enough for me to comment on. I had heard much about Rabbi Oshri, and know a son and son-in-law of his, but I never know the story behind the family. Truthfully, What I had seen and been taught about “Litvaks”, Litvishe Yidden, is a crime, but to that today’s “representatives” of Litvaks carry much of the blame, just as some Lubavitchers do a terrible job representing the Rebbe and Chassidus Chabad לדאבוננו הרב. We have been misled about these fine Yidden, and by “we” I mean all non-Litvisher.

Another point important to make is that although books like “Making of a Godol” weren’t meant to tell the heroic story of Jews during the Holocaust, they still have much to learn. They manage to go out of their way to criticize, belittle, and even embarrass friends of their family, Yeshiva Chaverim, and colleagues, all in the name of “truth”. Rabbi Oshry, even when discussing the history of certain towns, and even when mentioning totally irreligious Jews, rises above it all and does nothing of the kind. He mentions their heroics and even their Mesiras Nefesh for Yiddishkeit, which they had, and avoids the differences they had. I’m not sanctioning a total coverup of events, but there is a better way to go about it.

He begins by describing the initial days of the Nazi occupation of Lithuania, until then occupied by the Soviets, in June 1941, and how the Lithanian Goyim could not wait to get their hands on their Jewish neighbors. Even before the Germans had fully organized, the Litvishe Rotzchim were murdering with a brutality the Arabs in Chevron could’ve only hoped for.

That year June 22, the date of the German attack codenamed operation Barabossa, coincided with 27 Sivan. The next day a pogrom of never-before-seen proportions was carried out by their Christain neighbors and “friends”. In Kovno-Slabodka hundreds and hundreds of people were dragged out of their homes, off the streets, and out of Shuls, and beaten, stabbed, and literally chopped to death in the most calculated and gruesome ways by their Lithuanian neighbors without much German help at all.

The Slabodka Yeshivah, at the corner of Glezer and Furman Streets had to cease operations. The Bochurim just picked up and ran for their lives. REO writes: “Never will I forget that last morning, the 28th of Sivan 5701, June 23, 1941. On this day we stopped learning at the Slabodka Yeshivah; the sound of Torah study was heard for the final time on the corner of Glezer and Furman Streets." [ At that time, across the Atlantic, the Rebbe was arriving in New York, having escaped the Nazis and their Vichy allies in France.]

I cry for these Ballebatim, Rabbonim, Baalei Melochoh, Yeshivaleit, Bocherim, mener, vayber, un kinder, who have nobody to tell their story nor to carry on their traditions in this commercialized, cookie-cutter world of ours.

Excuse me if I’m a bit incoherent here, I’m still only an amateur “book critic”.

הרנינו גוים עמו כי דם עבדיו יקום ונקם ישוב לצריו וכפר אדמתו עמו

Does he belong in "Paradise"?



Matisyahu Miller has been getting lots of press these days, especially on Mentalblog. One comment that came from our friend Schneur hit home somewhat for me.

He questioned whether or not the Rebbe would've approved of what Matisyahu is doing, however good his intentions may be. He compares him to the late Shlomo Carlebach who asked the Rebbe if he can perform for mixed crowds, and the answer was NO. According to what Shlomo said they then parted ways, the Rebbe and Shlomo did. It seems a little too simplistic, that Shlomo only left for that reason, but that's a little beside the point. The point remains, he says, that the Rebbe was totally against the idea of a singer performing for mixed audiences.

Schneur continues: (paraphrasing)
Shlomo only sang in Loshon Kodesh (he did speak and sing in English, but his compositions were for the most part in Loshon HaKodesh) and sang in a very mellow way,no jumping or hip-hopping, yet he was forever banished from Chabad. Our friend Matisyahu goes further than any frum singer has ever gone, and then some, including performing on live TV and in nightclubs. I know all about him wearing the hat and jacket at his performances, and the sometimes removal of his glasses while performing, but what does that do? How much can a hat and jacket help for his own observance, and how does that change the content of his music?

I have been told and made to understand that there is one clear-cut difference here, namely that of Marriage. Shlomo was a Bochur and remained either a bachelor or single for most of his singing career. He also encouraged sing-along, especially the women, and mingled heavily with the attendees of his concerts. MM is married and does have somewhat of a set of guidelines as far as mingling is concerned. Do the dissimilarities end there? I'm not quite sure that they don't.

If it were only him performing in out of the way clubs, וואלט געווען א האלבע צרה , but now we've got so-called Shluchim going "mit di veib" to hear him perform as a night out on the town. Every Lubavitcher has a pure "heter" now to listen to the music because "er iz an unzerer" and even sings something that sounds like "Kol BaYaar" and "Tzomoh Lecho Nafshi"! hooray!

Mistama iz er vayler bocher and asked his Mashpiyim in HaDar Hatorah if he can continue and make this his career. What they were thinking, if they did give him the OK, is beyond me.

And you thought I couldn't be objective.

Tuesday, January 3, 2006

Clarifying the "מחדש" post



I have gotten numerous comments from people who read but "don't have time to comment" that if I really want to be objective then the Alter Rebbe was an even bigger Mechadesh in many different realms of Halachah. That being the case I shouldn't "pick fights". Again I'm being misunderstood.

The point of the post was not to bring out the fact that the Chazon Ish was mechadesh new guidelines in Shiurin D'Oraisoh, or that the Satmarer Rov had new ideas for Hilchos Avodo Zoroh. Rather, it was to bring out that those who scream about the "Mechadshim" had better check their own backyard first and see what their Rabbonim were Mechadesh, then decide if you want to condemn others.

"Rav Dessler" brings a story of how REED had in his posession a becher from his elter-zeide Reb Yisroel Salanter which his wife insisted he use for Kiddush every Shabbos. Now REED was of the opinion that the CI was the Moroh D'Asroh/Posek Acharon in B'nei Brak where he lived and his shiurim should be followed. The becher had no such shiur. He waited till his Rebbetzin passed away to use a bigger becher. In other words, according to the CI RYS never made a proper Kiddush.

Strange, no?

CORRECTION ON 1/6/15:
Upon reviewing the story I see that I inadvertently misquoted the book; The becher was a present from his uncle Reb Chaim Eyzer of Vilne, who received it from RYS. ואתכם הסליחה

"Rabbi Marulies walking home in Bucharest"


That's the caption of the photo by Yale Strom in 1985. Anybody know any more about the man? He's holding a "Divrei Yoel", so he seems like the "Head Meshilech" in Bucharest or maybe the whole of Romania? and no, there's no fun intended here, just a nice photo of a פארצייטישער איד און רב

Tell me more if you know something abut the man.

Monday, January 2, 2006

Let's play " Name that מחדש "

1) He decided that all Geonim, Tzaddikim, Rishonim and Acharonim, Tanoyim and Amoroyim never made Kiddush on a proper cup, never ate a proper Kezayis Matzoh, and never wore a full-size Tallis Koton among many others. Who was he?

A) The Chazon Ish
B) The Satmar Rov
C) The Lubavitcher Rebbe





2) He decided that all those who disagree with on issues of Tznius, Zionism, Hilchos Bais HaKnesses among others was not a credible Orthodox Rabbi. He also included speaking Hebrew into idol-worship, making it a cardinal sin. Who was he?

A) The Chazon Ish
B) The Satmar Rov
C) The Lubavitcher Rebbe





3) He decided that due to a total breakdown of Religious observance in America and the world over that some time must be taken from already free time and put to good use. Yeshivah students must use their free time to try and bring those Jews back. The same goes for married men and women, who should try and make a "career" out of it. Who was he?

A) The Chazon Ish
B) The Satmar Rov
C) The Lubavitcher Rebbe





NAME THAT !מחדש

winner takes home some fantastic prizes.......

Sunday, January 1, 2006

Kelmer Chinuch

"The Alter (of Kelm, HT) knew exactly what he was looking for in Talmidim: (of the Kelmer Talmud Torah, HT)

Those who will bear the yoke together ith friends without any thought of personal benefit or Kovod, and will commit themselves to conduct themselves according to my words and advice. Every Talmid had to pass the rigorous scrutiny of the Alter to be admitted. Only those posessing a refined manner, some wordly knowledge, a thirst for spiritual elevation, and, in most cases, a recommendation from their Mashgiach could hope to gain entry. " (Katz, Tenuas HaMussar)

How many of today's Talmidim would've passed that test?

Saturday, December 31, 2005

די מומע צילא



Tzila Schneersohn, wife of R' Ben-Zion, who was the brother-in-law of the Frierdige Rebbe passed away Thursday night. Who she was from home I do not know, but her husband's Yichus is simple.

He was the son of HaRav Avrohom Schneersohn of Kishinev, son of HaRaHa"K R' Yisroel Noach of Niezhin, son of the Tzemach Tzedek, N"E, who wrote the Tshuves of his father. RAS attended the Rebbe's wedding in Warsaw, in 5689.

RBZS was a Talmid of YTT in Lubavitch and lived in Tel Aviv after the WWII, working as a bookkeeper. He passed away in 5736. He's pictured here a BarMitzvah celebration in Israel.

(RBZphoto courtesy of ליובאוויטש וחייליה TS photo courtesy of shturem)

Friday, December 30, 2005

Gap Closing?



No, don't panic, it's not The Gap that's closing, you'll be able to shop there as long as you wish. It's this Chasidic-Misnagdic gap that's closing, at least according to David Of Lakewood. He must be a real teddy bear.

Thursday, December 29, 2005

"Alte Mirrers"

For blogger "Board of Directors", who had this to say on the Uriel Zimmer post:

"FYI: Not all of them were clean shaven, although MOST of them were.
But I can tell you that 99% of them grew beards and Peyos later on."

"THE biggest Alter Mirrer, Harav Hagoen R' Shmuel Berenbaum Shlita (Mirrer Rosh Yeshiva) has peyos.

BIG peyos."


(Photo - courtesy OORAH.org)




(Reb Shmuel Berenbaum today - CREDIT Mirrer Yeshiva News)


Can't argue that.



...............אבער אמאל




Rabbi Nachum Zev Dessler of Cleveland's "Hebrew Academy", aka Nochum Velvel, son of REED.






Summer Camp (L-R)Joshua Chinn, R. Moshe Shein, Harry Horowitz, ?, ?, ?, ?, ?,R. Simcha Weissman, Pinchas Berliner, R. Shmuel Birnbaum. Mottel Jaffe


One for the road.....



Yeshiva students and women in Mir family
(Pinchas Berliner top-left)

(Old Mirrer photos courtesy of darkwing.uoregon.edu)

and the most famous Mirrer of them all:



Schneur Zalman Rubashov, aka Zalman Shazar 3rd President of Israel, born Mir, 1885

(Photo courtesy of Shazar Center)

Wednesday, December 28, 2005

Would the opposite happen?




A story from "הרב מבריסק " [The life and times of HaRav IZ Soloveitchik of Brisk] edited for brevity:

בערבו של חג שלחו להודיע למרן זצ"ל כי מונח עבורו אתרוג תחת ידיו של האדמו"ר הריי"צ שניאורסון מליובאוויטש, שהתגורר בקצה מרוחק של העיר, מרחק כמה שעות הליכה מאכסנייתו של מרן זצ"ל. הדרך הייתה בחזקת סכנה, כאשר כל העת חגים מפציצים כבדים בשמיה של וורשה ומטילים טונות של פצצות, שיצרו עם הגיעם אל הארץ עיי חרבות, וזרעו הרס רב. בחור בעל לב חם לתורה ומצוותיה, מחסידי גור, נדבה אותו רוחו והוא הציע חרף הסיכון הרב, שהוא ילך אל ביתו של האדמו"ר הריי"צ על מנת להביא את האתרוג. מרן זצ"ל הרהר קימעא, ולאחר שהפך בהצעה נטה להסכים לה, בהטעימו כי אם בעת צרה כזו ליעקב ישנו יהודי המוכן למסור את נפשו עבור קיום מצווה, אין הוא רשאי למנוע בעדו מלעשות כן. השעה הייתה תשע בערב, כאשר אותו בחור אכן יצא אל הרחוב המסוכן על מנת להביא את האתרוג. אולם, רק בסביבות השעה ארבע לפנות בוקר שב לאכסנייתו של מרן זצ"ל כשבחיקו טמון האתרוג היקר. הבחור סיפר כי האיזור בו התגורר אז הרבי הריי"צ ספג אותו לילה פצצות רבות, והרבי נאלץ לברוח ממקום למקום מאימת ההפגזות. כך יצא שרק בתום חיפושים מייגעים מהכא להתם ומהתם להכא, הצליח לפגוש באדמו"ר הריי"צ שנטל עמו את האתרוג היקר לכל מקום שאליו הגיע במנוסתו ממטוסי המלחמה. עם האוצר יקר-הערך שקיבל מידיו של הרבי, שב הבחור הנמרץ עם שחר לאכסנייתו של הרב מבריסק

"In short, they say, that a Gerrer Bochur ran around Warsaw on the night before Succos in October 1939 dodging German bombs looking for the Esrog that the Frierdige Rebbe N"E was guarding with his life for the Brisker Rov. The Rebbe had to run from place to place to avoid the bombardment. To highlight to the reader how rare an Esrog was that year, a line of thousands of people waited outside where the Rebbe stayed in order to fulfill the Mitzvah on the first day of Succos!

In actuality it was Rabbi Yosef Wineberg לאויוש"ט who was sent by the FR to deliver the Esrog to the BR.

Why the Rebbe chose to give this Esrog to the BR, although there were many, many other Rabbonim and Tzaddikim in Warsaw, many more friendly to Lubavitch than the BR, who would've gladly been the recipient of this prized esrog is not something I'll venture to answer. The Rebbe had his reasons, I'm sure.

My question is: Would the BR have risked his life and the life of a Talmid to do the same for the Rebbe?

The Rebbe's קנאי



9 Kislev marks 44 years since the passing of Reb Uriel Zimmer z"l.

Some of his life's accomplishments:

Spoke 17 (!) languages



(at a UN function)

wrote for Lubavitch and "Der Yid" at the same time!


(Booklet on Mezuzah)

Translated the Tanya into Yiddish.



l-r: Unknown, Reb Uriel, Reb Pinye Althoyz, Reb Yaakov Yosef Raskin


RUZ was a devoted Chossid of the Rebbe despite being so anti-State, and maybe because of that.

Read an Article in The Israeli weekly "פנים אל פנים" after his passing.




(Photos courtesy of Shturem-Chabadnik and other sources)

Monday, December 26, 2005

The Menayreh of HirshelTzig



Small, yet respectable.

Big, yet not ostentacious.

Just like it should be.

Thank You Shver and Shvigger.

Reb Shimon Shept Nachas

Seeing his townspeople participating in a public Menorah-lighting in Grodno, proud to be Jewish after all these years. These people are probably descendants of Reb Shimon Shkop's Talmidim and Ba'alei Batim, or maybe people who arrived after the war. It's good to see that both their physical and spiritual needs are attended to.


(Photo courtesy of Shturem)