We 
once spoke about sifrei kodesh published in Hungarian pre-WW2 and how we were surprised to see it. We thought that despite the fact that we have our 
Bubbe's צאינה וראינה in Hungarian that in circles such as Pupa, this wasn't done. At lest that's the way 
Pupa would portray itself today... That's what happens when you live in 
Satmar's shadow for 60+ years... Then again the whole 
issur against foreign languages is a bit unclear. Was it only in 
shul that it was 
assur? Only 
drashos so as to separate from the 
neologen? In some 
shuls it was 
assur to speak Hungarian, which shows you that Hungarian was the language of choice and that they wanted to uproot that 
minhag.  In any case we have for you today, courtesy of veteran reader Yosef718, several pages of a book that was published by 
HaRav Shulem Vider הי"ד  of Nyíregyháza pre-WW2 and then reprinted in 1947 by the VH in Munich, and then later in Montreal. On the VH copy a woman remembers her sister, and in the Montreal copy a different woman had scribbled the telephone number of the 
Kicsi Pupa Rebbetzin, o"h. The 
hakdomoh in 
Yiddish is from his son 
Reb Shlomo Dov Vider of Montreal. There he writes that the Orthodox קאנציליי, gatekeepers of the 
Teilung, if you will, original 
teilung organizers, were the ones that had this published.
Quite ironic.
 
.jpg) 
.jpg) 
 Harav Shulem Vider, hy"D.
Harav Shulem Vider, hy"D. 
Photo courtesy of Yad Vashem.
3 comments:
Hirshel
did you realize That Rav vieder starts out with the story of the Berdichver ruv on the sefer tanya?
this Issur on using Hoch German or Hungarian was forced upon the real manhigim of the orthodoxy by a very vocal minority...we will leave it for a other day
its the same as when the mosdos ask you for money. all the correspondence is in yiddish/lh"k the bill comes in english....
Not a Harry
its as the mosdos have you sign for no computer in your house, and all their billings,litreture for the kids and write-ups are done on a computer and via Internet
Post a Comment