Tuesday, June 17, 2014

....פלוגתא דר' דוד ור' אברהם בהגרי"ז

בהמשך להמדובר לעיל about Reb Moshe's psak to be מצרף any Jew to any דבר שבקדושה; here's what the Brisker Rov is to have said about this: Not so clear to you? well, it's a pretty murky situation. That's the problem here. Each one has his story with the BR and each one has a nice lomdus to go with it! I guess it depends on who was asking, what was going on a the time, and בכלל - the general מצב רוח. You can only wait so long for a צענטער... I'm just glad we're not meant to pasken halochoh leMa'aseh from Meller's books. Were there any comments about Reb Moshe from the Brisker Rov, or did that start post the המ"ר?




6 comments:

Not a Harry said...

ישר כחך הירשל לייבען. נקודת החקירה, אם יש לו דין עכו"ם מה אכפת לן אם אפיקורס הוא או לא. ע"כ נלענ"ד

Hirshel Tzig - הירשל ציג said...

ברוך שכוונת

יש לחלק said...

יש לחקור וצריך עיון איך חל הצווי דינים

Charkover said...

Hey tzig, I thought you were a maskil not a Lamdan?

Hirshel Tzig - הירשל ציג said...

what gave you that idea?

מרדכי said...

יבוא ר' אברהם יהושע ויכריע ביניהם
Who wants to volunteer to ask למען הכולל