Thursday, November 16, 2017

Why is Mishpacha Mag going after the "Peleg"

Beats me. I think they're alienating many readers with this article. No need to bring it up at all. They don't gain readers from publishing it. It's not like they're writing about Lubavitch of Reb Hershel Schechter and thus adding YU Yeshivishers or Lubavitchers to their readership. Here it's a lose-lose. Plenty of their readers are Mamshichisten and thus see Reb Shmuel as their mentor and leader. They support the demonstrations and are deeply hurt by the fact that their Yeshivishe brothers are selling them out. Just stick to the usual veyberishe issues and you'll be ok. You hear me Rabbi Grylak? I know from what I'm talking.

   Peleg by Hirshel Tzig on Scribd

20 comments:

yair said...

why nit ?

ks said...


Mamshichisten? is that the new buzz word

Hirshel Tzig - הירשל ציג said...

Not new and therefore not a buzz word

א מיינונג אזא said...

Are you really that dense? Do you not know the history?
Find out what Grylak's first writing job was. Find out who kicked him out. Find out what אמנת כנרת was and who fought it.

P. S. The mamshichisten (a term I heard over five years ago) would anyway not buy te mishpacha.

Chalmers said...

"Find out what Grylak's first writing job was. Find out who kicked him out. Find out what אמנת כנרת was and who fought it."

Yes, Grylak was the original editor of Yated. It seems Nati Grossman replaced him. (He's written in Mishpacha against Nati previously.) What was the issue over? And who made this decision and why?

But what's ?אמנת כנרת

A Reader said...

sorry I don't do politics.

Anonymous said...

Writing against those criminally insane gangsters of Peleg is an absolute no- brainer,how could a normal person defend this absolute gangster-ism,the only ones supporting this ZAKEN MAMRE are the crazies of the Aida Hachraidis
CHAIM

Yankel M said...

you are wrong
The extreme guys in the USA who side with the Peleg guys are the same guys that are boycotting Ami and Mishpacha
So why not give them a good flick
lots of logic to this approach

א מיינונג אזא said...

Some years ago, some not very bright characters decided that there was some kind of war between Charedim and chilonim in the middle east and they decided to convene a summit between representatives of the warring sides. They appointed themselves and met with some chilonim who were happy to hear that they represent their brethren in Chiloniism at a hotel at the Kinneret.
Some not very bright characters decided that this non-event was somewhat dangerous to the true hashkafa of the bright guys and wrote article after article denouncing their fellow not very bright characters.

Kad vahad said...

When rav alyashuv was ill and we were all saying תהילים after dovining i saw a senior mishpacha walk out and פורש מן הצבור...

vos vu vehn said...

im new here

after reading the profile "About Me -א יונגערמאן אין עולם הזה trying to do what's right. The purpose of this blog was to provide a counter opinion to the Chabad bashing ..."-

im wondering what this post is doing on this blog???!!?!

Yehuda said...

Selling them about? The Peleg hypocrites and their leader (whose signature hasn't been accepted for years in many gemachim) are the biggest rodfim of the oilom hatoroh in the world. Naive American armchair zealots who understand nothing and for whom this is a big game need to be put in their place.

Simcha said...

Do me a favour. Does any sane person support this: http://mobile.kikar.co.il/article/256959

הוי רועה ישראל said...

בעקבות הפגיעות בגר"י רוזן פרסם מרן שר התורה הגר״ח קנייבסקי מחאה חסרת תקדים על אלו אותם הגדיר כ"הולכים כצאן ללא רועה

Wow said...

http://m.bhol.co.il/article.aspx?id=126275

Sassoon said...

Simcha: "Do me a favour."

of course:
https://youtu.be/5SQ7Zmk2-Zg

I second said...

nu?

XIVVII said...

"Stalin, with his brutal sense of humour, asked The Pope? How many divisions does he have?”

Shish..this said...

One of the most well-known activists who works to rescue detainees from the courts by means of various legal means is Rabbi Shimon Shisha, who is a member of the Eida Charedis. He also assists detainees from the Peleg, many of whom were arrested during protests held in recent weeks.

Shisha is considered to be familiar with the legal and military system and is active in this field and often serves as the attorney for the detainees before the enforcement authorities.

On Monday night, a number of yeshiva students were arrested at the induction center on Rashi Street. One of the demonstrators feared that there was an arrest of one for failing to report for service, one of whom was arrested without shoes.

Shisha arrived to address the situation and did indeed see one Yeshiva Bochur that was arrested without shoes. Without hesitation, he took off his own shoes and gave them to the detainee and he returned home without them.

(YWN – Israel Desk, Jerusalem)

news and brews said...

Jerrold Nadler will become the ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee after Rep. John Conyers announced he would step down from his post.