E15th and J. Not Kosher.In the last couple of years,
Chabad’s presence in Flatbush has increased and there are several “shluchim” who actually make a difference in people’s lives. Recently, the
Lubavitcher yungerman who runs the operation on Ave J, has been admitted as a full time student
Kollel Gur Aryeh on Coney Island; a testimony as to how
Chabad has been “accepted” by the
Yeshiva World and how times are changing -for better and for worse. Be that as it may, IMHO, the fact that
Lubavitch is having success is not a good sign for the community. It is a manifestation of Flatbush’s un-
Torahdikeh environment. To put it simply: if Flatbush would be a stronghold for serious yeshivaleit, the reaction to
Chabad would not be as welcoming. IOW: the “welcoming” of
Chabad, is an indication – perhaps a subtle one – that true
Bney Teyreh are persona non grata.
My friends,It is not easy being a
Ben Teyreh in Flatbush. First there is the education of the
kinderlach. Contrary to Lakewood where provided one is deemed a “true
ben Teyreh or has pull, you can have your pick of many different levels of exclusive
chadorim, in Flatbush you have no other choice but to send the kids to a “community” school where there kids of all stripes and denominations. Then there is the actual standard of living. In Flatbush, it is much harder and less socially acceptable to be on the “
programmin”. One doesn’t have the luxury of living with other
yungerleit in a claustrophobic attached-on-both-sides development where one is not expected to have two cars. To make the problem worse, Flatbush has been recently invaded by a group of tuna-bagels (TEE-NUH BAY-GILS) who erected this monstrous edifice known as the
POMEGRANATE. For many of your neighbors, they associate a religious experience with walking into that store and being awed by the variations of
galah, herring, dips with the take out section of fish, meat and fresh baked goods (let’s not get started with the different types of six-hour cheeses). Obviously, a true-blooded sensitive
Ben Torah does not feel at home in an ostentatious environment of overindulgence,
luxus, and materialism – even if his family
shtams from the
Oberland.
Treif too.Of course, In Lakewood, many can eventually afford to buy a house – somehow. Once the down payment is accounted for, the mortgage can be paid by renting out the basement to Pedro Sr., with Pedro Jr. and more importantly, Pedro III – the ticket to everyone’s citizenship – whose tuition at the local public school is covered by the property tax paid by the
oylam. In Flatbush, if you are not an SY, or you don’t have a rich uncle, there is no way it is going to be feasible to buy a house [unless, you want to buy next door to a
Beis Menahcem, vedal]. That means that if you want to learn in Flatbush, you probably would have to move to Marine Park (also not so cheap) or to Kensington. Perhaps the biggest problem is more of a nuanced and subtle and is of the sociological nature. You see, in Lakewood, the
bal-ha-batim know their place and many of the relatively younger ones have an inferiority complex that they are “working” [unless they do “very well”]. Basically, although no one really says it publically, the working class is expected to accept their fate and acknowledge – at least subtlety- that they sit where Rosa Parks refused to. In Flatbush, in the last ten years, this is has all changed. The reason, in short:
Rav Avrumy Schorr.
Rav Avrumy has changed the way the Flatbush working guy, whose years of
hasmadah and
cheshek in
Yiddishkeit (if it ever existed) are something of the distant past. He has rejuvenated many and now the
bal-ha-bus can walk with a spring in his gait. He is special. He gets to hear the standard
reyd from the
Poylishe seforim (sprinkled with some other sources) on a weekly basis. Unlike ones not-so-fond memories of days in yeshiva with “boring”
melamdim - this new
Rebbe is dynamic. His face can turn beet red, as long as he is twirling his
peyos with enough concentration. He follows in the way of the
Beis Yisroel as he paces up and down the aisles and stares – and he does not have a chair by his seat, ala the
Beis Yisroel. Rav Avrumy, who has family member who are respected
Chassidim, due no doubt to his impressive resume and tenure in many
yeshivas, has learned the age old trick in building people’s self-esteem and making them feel good: “
muhn” something from the crowd. There is no better source of self pride than having an authority figure actually expect something from you! But I must say,
Rav Avrumy perfected this age-old technique. Instead of “just”
muhning, he actually speaks about things and
hasagos that are much higher than where the
oylam is holding. As a result, one can have the proverbial cake and eat it to; get “
muhned” and feel no need to change one’s life one iota – just sit back and enjoy the monologue. Although,
Rav Avrumy has finally found his calling and his presence is overall beneficial to the denizens of Flatbush, it is questionable on its affect on transforming Flatbush into an
ihr v’aym b'yisroel.
